Drought & Ranch Management

How does drought impact grasses?

Understanding how moisture stress affects plants is essential when designing drought management practices.

Native prairie plants are well adapted to low and variable precipitation. However, severe, prolonged drought will reduce plant numbers and vigor. And last year's precipitation and defoliation (grazing) will affect this year's forage production. Here's why:

Plant Growth

Process of photosynthesis

Carbohydrates produced from photosynthesis provide energy for all plant growth and maintenance. When air temperatures are favorable for plant growth, lack of soil moisture is the limiting factor for photosynthesis.

Plant growth is reduced or delayed when green leaf area is removed, or when soil moisture limits the amount of carbohydrates that can be produced. Overgrazing and drought during the plant’s rapid growth windows will reduce next year's plant growth.

Plants rely on stored energy to survive during dormancy, and for initial growth after dormancy.Plants must rely on stored energy for unusually long periods of time when drought-induced summer dormancy is added to winter dormancy. Early spring growth that is stopped by drought or frost will deplete the plant’s energy reserves and reduce forage production potential the following year.

Plant Reproduction

Little Bluestem buds

Multiple cadres of buds occur on little bluestem crowns ranging from 1-year-old (a) to 3-year-old (b) generations. Image:  Pat Reece

Each year’s forage crop is produced by a new set of tillers that develops from buds located in the crown and on rhizomes or stolons.

Year-to-year replacement of grass tillers primarily depends on the production and survival of vegetative buds on existing plants. Few perennial grasses become established from seed on rangeland.

Reduced plant growth under drought conditions or excessive grazing before grasses head may reduce or eliminate formation of new buds. Severe drought will lead to severe die off of tillers and rhizomes.

Grazing pastures every year at the same time, when root growth, bud formation, stolon growth and/or rhizome growth are seasonally most rapid, will reduce next year’s forage production of most mid-grasses and tall-grasses.

What’s a plant’s rapid growth window?

Rangeland plant communities are naturally composed of mixtures of species that primarily grow at different times during the spring or summer. Grasses are classified as cool-season or warm-season species generally based on their growth response to air temperature.

Rapid growth windows of warm and cool season plants

Maximum growth rates of most cool-season (C3) species occur when air temperatures are 65 to 75F compared to 90 to 95F for many warm-season (C4) grasses. Considerable variation occurs in the range of air temperatures over which measurable growth occurs within each season-of-growth category.

Rapid growth occurs in grasses when air temperatures and soil water are simultaneously favorable. Rapid rates of herbage production are associated with stem elongation. Optimum air temperatures differ among species. For example, 50 to 80 percent of the annual herbage production of most species occurs during a 30-day time period for mid- and tallgrasses on semiarid rangeland.

These rapid-growth windows are best defined by growing degree days. The sequence of rapid-growth windows for different species is the same each year; however, initiation of rapid growth may change by one to two weeks as cumulative degree days change from year to year.

Can Overgrazing Leave Grass Vulnerable to Drought?

Increased Grazing Pressure = Increased Tiller Defoliation

Vegetative, elongation, and reproductive stages of plant growth
Developmental Stages of Grass Growth Image: Iowa State University PM1791

Cattle are selective grazers. They select immature tillers over mature tillers and leaves over stems.

Livestock use of each grass species tends to be highest when tillers are vegetative, and predominantly leaves. Livestock may defoliate over 50% of preferred mid- and tallgrasses early in the growing season.

Livestock use becomes progressively lower as tillers age or transition into seed stalks. The opportunity for livestock to select a high quality diet becomes stocking-rate sensitive through the balance of the growing season.

As grazing pressure increase, both the percentage of tillers grazed and percent defoliation of grazed tillers will increase. If most of the tillers are grazed while they are elongating, next year's herbage production is likely to be reduced. Learn how to determine when cool- and warm-season grasses are elongating, or in rapid growth windows.

Stocking rate and grazing system decisions are most likely to affect animal performance in the second half of the grazing season. In contrast, these decisions are most likely to affect plant vigor and herbage production potential during the first half of the summer grazing season. When precipitation is average or above average, preferred grass species generally recover from grazing stress by the end of the current growing season, if pastures are grazed before their respective rapid-growth windows (marked by stem elongation) and then deferred until killing frost. However, when moisture is inadequate, declines in subsequent-year herbage production are likely to be greatest for preferred plant species grazed during rapid growth.

"Take Half & Leave Half" May Reduce Next Year's Plant Production, Vigor

Subsequent-year herbage (lb/ac) is dependent upon percent of defoliation in current year

The "Take Half & Leave Half" mantra implies that removing up to 50% of the herbage has no ill effect on individual species. However, a recent study shows that 50% defoliation of the warm-season tallgrass, prairie sandreed, during its rapid-growth window, actually reduced its subsequent-year herbage production by about 20% (see figure).

The only option available to grazing managers is to shift grazing in the subsequent-year to a time that precedes or follows rapid-growth windows of preferred species.

Overgrazing Leads to Fewer Plant Roots

plant root depth over time

Plant vigor and plant species composition affect the soil depth from which vegetation uses moisture.

Roots are sensitive to defoliation; heavy defoliation of green plants stops root growth for one to two weeks. Reduction in root length often corresponds to decline in plant vigor.

The percentage of total root length lost increases as root depth increases. Losses of deep roots are measurably greater than loss of shallow roots in tallgrasses. Short grasses often increase as range condition declines.

The figure at right shows the percent of total root length (sand bluestem) in each depth of soil compared to plants not clipped until October, after killing frost. (Modified from Engel et al. 1998) Defoliation in June and August resulted in the biggest losses of root length at all soil depths.

Heavy Grazing + Drought = Double Loss of Perennial Plant Cover

Grazing intensity had a dramatic impact on the reduction of perennial plant cover during the 1950’s drought in the Great Plains. Moderate grazing generally caused little change in cover compared to un-grazed sites. Heavy grazing nearly doubled the loss of perennial plant cover caused by drought alone.

Can my grazing practices influence how much moisture is in the soil?

Soil water is the most limiting plant growth factor on semi-arid rangelands. Grazing management influences the effectiveness of precipitation and soil moisture.

Plant Cover Improves Soil Moisture

Plant and soil interactions

Adequate plant cover must be left to optimize infiltration, the amount of precipitation that enters the soil.

Standing herbage and plant litter on the soil surface break the impact of rain drops on the soil and provide a physical barrier to runoff.

Plant litter and standing herbage reduce evaporation losses by moderating extremes in soil surface temperatures and by protecting the soil against drying winds.

Soil Compaction Leads to Runoff, Decreased Soil Moisture

Water intake (in/hr) of clay loam, silt, loamy sand, and sand in high vs low condition

Soil compaction and reduced protective plant cover generally reduce infiltration and increase runoff during heavy precipitation.

The potential for damaging soil structure or compacting soil generally is greater on wet compared to dry soils and greater on fine textured clayey or silty soils compared to coarse textured sandy soils. 

Numerous studies of livestock effects on rangeland watersheds conclude: non-grazed areas have higher infiltration rates than grazed areas. Heavy grazing reduces infiltration more than moderate or light grazing.

Practices to Optimize Use of Precipitation

Leaving adequate remaining herbage and allowing preferred species to maintain healthy root systems are the best approaches available for ranchers to optimize use of precipitation.

Year-to-year changes in pasture-use sequences, periodic full growing-season deferment, and moderate stocking rates can be used to enhance root length and function.

Overgrazing may cause drought-like conditions even with average precipitation.

For more on best management practices to optimize soil moisture, see "Before Drought"

How does drought affect livestock nutrition and gain?

Forage Quality and Livestock Performance

Performance of livestock is a function of nutrient requirements and intake. The quantity and quality of available forage are the primary regulators of nutrient intake in grazing cattle. Animal performance will decline whenever remaining forage falls below a minimum level.

Average daily gain (lbs/head/day) over time
Seasonal patterns in average daily gain of different classes of livestock during the summer grazing season over a 15 year time period in north central Colorado (Klipple and Costello 1960)

Even when drought does not occur, animal performance declines as the summer grazing season progresses (see figure at right). These seasonal declines correspond to advancing plant maturity. When drought occurs, calf gain during late summer may be entirely from the "back fat of the cow."

If plant growth is stopped by drought, forage quality may decline rapidly because livestock selectively graze the highest quality forage first. The rate of decline in forage quantity and quality during drought is much more pronounced than in an average growing season.

Drought often reduces the number of days during which green forage is available to livestock. However, forage that cures at early stages of plant development can provide higher than average quality during mid and late summer. Ranchers who adequately reduce stocking rates to account for reduced quantities of forage under drought conditions often experience above average animal performance.

Conception and Lactation

Nutritional deficiencies also have an adverse effect on conception rates, especially if cows are thin at calving. Conception rates will first decline in lactating first-calf heifers because they still need nutrients for growth, in contrast to mature cows.

Lactation increases cow nutrient requirements substantially. Continued nursing further delays a cow's return to estrus when nutritional deficiencies occur. Early weaning of calves may be the most efficient management practice available for maintaining reproductive performance when nutritional stress occurs.

What are the financial risks of drought?

Financial Benefits of Drought Planning

Drought comes with both direct and indirect costs. Whatever actions are taken to mitigate drought, there is always an associated cost, whether it be physical or psychological.

From the economic perspective drought mitigation is managed from two main objectives – demand management and supply management.

Demand management options include decreasing the demand for inputs such as selling livestock, weaning calves early and moving them to a drylot or sale, and decreasing the grazing time in various pasture.

Supply management includes options that increase the supply of forage and/or water by digging a well, trucking water to livestock, renting additional pasture, grazing alternative forages such as crop residue, and trucking livestock further distances to obtain additional pasture. 

With rare exception, all of these options incur cost either by increasing expenses or decreasing future revenues. While it may not be possible to incur no cost as the result of drought, it is possible to prepare. The more prepared you are, the more options you will have to mitigate drought, and hopefully, that will lead to a smaller impacts to you, your family and your livelihood and way of life.

Drought and cattle markets

Market prices for cattle and beef fluctuate both seasonally and cyclically. When you combine such phenomenon with local conditions, such as drought, the amount of risk may be amplified. 

Using drought management strategies, a producer may be able to exploit the market fluctuations and use them to alleviate heavy financial losses. 

For example, it is commonly observed that cull cow prices generally bottom out in late fall, say November. If this seasonality effect is preceded by prolonged drought in your area, you could expect that your local market may see a flood of more cull cows than is normal for the season. This even further dampens local prices, and makes a very poor time and place to sell cull cows.

If, however, you had culled heavily in the spring, you would probably have gotten a better price for your culls, and you would have conserved more pasture or range.

The earlier you can anticipate drought and be prepared to manage it, you are more likely to avoid unfavorable market conditions and decrease your loss. In essence, early drought management provides greater flexibility and enhances your capability to avert unfavorable market conditions and "must sell" situations.

Seasonality in Choice Boxed Beef Prices (below)

Chioce boxed beef cutout values, 2008-2010

Seasonality in Slaughter Steer Prices (below)

Nebraska direct slaughter steer prices

Cyclical Pattern in Real Calf Prices (below)

Real calf prices 500 pounds or less from the early 1900's

Risks associated with a drought

The two kinds of risk generally associated with a drought are production risk and market risk. 

Production risk naturally emanates from the fact that drought limits forage production and availability, which directly limits the total productivity of the operation. 

Increased market risk is realized when those affected by drought act in unison and dump animals on the market in an untimely manner.

To mitigate as much of this risk as possible, producers should have a viable drought management plan. Such a plan will not only specify all the options of demand and supply management strategies but may also use some form of insurance product where offered.

A viable plan needs to have several characteristics. These characteristics include being able to identify key decision points. As will be shown in the section titled “Before a Drought Section- Financial Considerations" a series of smaller decisions can be effective in mitigating drought impact on the operation.

Drought conditions occur over time sometimes making it difficult to take immediate action. A viable plan will provide a method of making decisions in a timely manner and in a less stressful way.

The key factor to remember in building a plan is that all of the options need to be carefully evaluated based on their cost of implementation and then use the combination of least cost options. In addition to the demand and supply management strategies one generally thinks about, insurance products and marketing tools should also be integrated where they can help mitigate risk.